The College Football Playoff selection committee released its first Top 25 of the 2026 season on Tuesday, and CBS Sports columnists used it to argue the rankings favored the SEC and slighted Notre Dame.
The column says the committee added a strength-of-conference metric this year. According to the column, all six two-loss SEC teams rank higher in the CFP poll than in the AP and coaches polls. Alabama at No. 5 and Texas at No. 7 are both ranked above undefeated UCLA at No. 8. The column also notes that nine of the 16 SEC teams would make a 24-team playoff field if it were played Tuesday night.
Notre Dame debuted at No. 11. Committee chairman Hunter Yurachek said the team "doesn't have that signature win." The column calls the seven-spot gap from the AP poll the largest difference in the initial rankings. The writer says Notre Dame's remaining schedule includes one top-25 opponent, Miami, which is ranked No. 1.
The column also questions Alabama's ranking. It says Alabama is 2-2 against CFP top-25 teams and that Yurachek cited a win at Mississippi State as impressive. The writer says Mississippi State was missing quarterback Kamario Taylor to injury.
Yurachek also said the committee does not weigh head-to-head results as heavily as many fans assume, citing Ohio State's win over Indiana. Ohio State is ranked No. 12, the first team out of the field, according to the column.
The column notes that the committee's metrics are not public and that rankings can change weekly.