Drew Mestemaker led a shakeup in Sporting News's updated stock watch for the top quarterbacks in the 2027 NFL Draft class. The report says the class looks different than it did in September, and it raises two open questions: whether any quarterback is a can't-miss prospect and whether top names will return to school.

Mestemaker threw for 323 yards and five touchdowns in a road loss to Iowa State, his seventh interception of the season. The report says Notre Dame's Carr has thrown one interception in eight starts and could become a high first-round prospect if he keeps avoiding turnovers. Miami's Mensah threw for 274 yards and three touchdowns, and the report says his completion rate is above 80 percent. It identifies arm strength as the main concern about his NFL outlook.

Texas quarterback Manning had three touchdowns and four incompletions against Mississippi State. The report says he needs more performances like that to prove he deserves a top-10 pick. Oregon's Moore has a season that is over while he recovers from a concussion. He must decide between using his fifth year of eligibility and entering the NFL.

The report says Chambliss threw for 263 yards and three total touchdowns against Auburn, though turnovers have been a recent problem. It cites size and age as concerns. USC's Maiava threw for 222 yards on 22 attempts against Ohio State without a turnover. South Carolina's Sellers threw for 301 yards and 96 rushing yards against Oklahoma, with two interceptions and five total touchdowns. The report says he is not yet polished enough for teams to gamble on him early. Ole Miss's Simmons threw for 179 yards in a game against Arkansas.