Gotham FC enters the NWSL playoffs as the favorite after finishing first in the regular season and winning the Shield. The team meets the Seattle Reign in the quarterfinal on Sunday, Nov. 8, at 12:30 p.m. ET at Sports Illustrated Stadium in Harrison, N.J. ABC will broadcast the game, and it will stream on the ESPN App. Odds listed in the report are Gotham FC -150, a draw at +265 and Seattle Reign +340.
The report describes Gotham as the league's new dynasty. It says the Shield win was the club's fifth major title in three years. Gotham has played most of its past playoff games as the lowest seed, and it won the championship twice in those games. This quarterfinal is the first in which it enters as the clear favorite, according to the report.
Jaedyn Shaw has 14 goals and seven assists in 35 NWSL games with Gotham. She joined the club in September 2025. Rose Lavelle, who plays alongside Shaw, has become a standout. Tierna Davidson has become captain. Head coach Juan Carlos Amoros praised the pair's work rate. After a September win over the Chicago Stars, Amoros said both players commit to defense and hard work.
Shaw said Lavelle's movement is among the best in the world. Shaw described Lavelle as smart and said she is trying to copy her play.
Sam Kerr has scored four times since returning to the NWSL on July 16, despite ranking third in the league with 9.67 expected goals over that span, according to the report. Jordyn Dudley will miss the playoffs with a foot fracture. The report says Lavelle and Shaw returned from small injuries late in the regular season.
The report says most of Gotham's likely starters joined the club after the 2023 playoff run. It names Ann-Katrin Berger, the 2024 goalkeeper of the year, and European champion Jess Carter as examples.