Damien Harris made a strong case on CBS Sports that Jeremiah Smith should skip the rest of Ohio State's season. His argument rests on the Buckeyes' position: a 41-28 loss to No. 23 Oregon left them with three losses and three games to play, and Harris said the team is not a College Football Playoff team and will not play for a Big Ten Championship. I think the logic is understandable but the conclusion is wrong.
Start with what the report actually shows about Smith's season. He caught seven passes for 133 yards and a touchdown against Oregon, and he entered the day second nationally in receiving yards per game. He is one of the Heisman frontrunners entering Week 10 and has a good shot at his first Biletnikoff Award. None of that is diminished by a bad team result. A receiver playing at that level has every reason to keep building his résumé, especially with an NFL Draft run that the report says he is projected to lead.
Harris's point that Smith has already secured his place in program history is fair as far as it goes. He holds program records for receptions, touchdowns, and receiving yards, and he won a national championship as a freshman in 2024. But the report also notes that Smith was frustrated in the fourth quarter, and that his targets were inconsistent in the loss. Those are exactly the problems a player fixes by staying on the field. Quarterback Luke Fahey threw for 360 yards, and the timing between the two is the kind of thing that improves only with reps.
The injury argument deserves a direct answer. The report notes that college contracts can now be structured to protect players, much as NFL players are protected when their teams are out of contention. Ohio State has Michigan in the finale, a rivalry game that carries weight for every player who wears the uniform. Walking away from that is not self-protection; it is a choice to skip the moments that define a college career.
My verdict is simple: Smith should keep playing. The Buckeyes' season may be slipping, but his own season is not over, and the best way to protect his draft value is to finish it strong.