Ferrari's problem is not that its two drivers race each other. It is that the team has not decided what it wants from them. After the Mexico City Grand Prix, a first-lap clash between Lewis Hamilton and Charles Leclerc, running first and second at the time, cost the Italian team a likely one-two, and Max Verstappen went on to win. Hamilton was openly critical of Leclerc afterwards, and team principal Fred Vasseur also expressed his displeasure at the incident.
Damon Hill's argument, made on Sky Sports' The F1 Show, is that Ferrari should resolve this by making Hamilton the number one driver. Hill said the team has invested heavily in Hamilton, that he is "a massive name in the sport," and that the team cannot win the Drivers' and Constructors' Championships while its drivers keep racing each other like this. He also argued that Hamilton has "rebuilt himself" after the 2021 title loss and called him "an extraordinary individual" who has taken pole positions and won races for Ferrari this year.
I think Hill is right about the need for a decision, though not necessarily about the answer. Hamilton's form in 2026 is real. His first grand prix win for Ferrari in Barcelona and his pole positions this season are facts that a team principal cannot ignore. Leclerc's record is also strong, with nine grand prix wins across eight campaigns with the team. Hamilton is fourth in the standings, just 12 points ahead of Leclerc, which is hardly a gap that settles a hierarchy on its own.
Anthony Davidson made the more useful point. Preferential treatment, he said, should be earned through performance, as Verstappen has done at Red Bull, and he was uncomfortable with the idea that one driver is simply the number one regardless of where the other finishes. That is the right test. Ferrari should not give Hamilton the status because of his name or his investment history. If the team decides Hamilton is its best bet for the title, it should say so, set clear rules for the first corner and for team orders, and accept the consequences for Leclerc.
My verdict is that Ferrari should make the call now rather than let the factions in the team settle it through the media. Hill's concern about a political problem inside the team is the strongest part of his case. Whichever driver the team backs, the decision needs to be explicit, consistent and made by the team principal, not by whichever driver is quickest to complain after a race.