New York reportedly came close to adding Jonathan Taylor before Tuesday's NFL trade deadline. According to Jay Glazer, the Giants at one point had a 2nd- and 5th-round pick on the table for the Colts running back. The deal never came together, and John Harbaugh did not add to his backfield at all. Given how the rest of the week unfolded, that outcome looks like the better one.
The deadline was not the only thing on the line. Skattebo had struggled for much of his 2026 season. After an 81-yard outing in Week 1, Harbaugh benched him in Week 6 over fumbling issues, and Tyrone Tracy, Najee Harris and Devin Singletary all took more reps. Harris was eventually released. A 124-yard game against the Texans in Week 7 suggested a bounce-back, but the Giants still looked at outside options. Tony Pollard was another name considered, and nothing materialized.
Then came Thursday night. Skattebo was the engine of New York's offense in a 24-21 loss to the Commanders, running for 78 yards and two touchdowns and adding three catches for 44 yards. It was his first multi-touchdown game since October 2025. One good game does not settle a running back's season, and the report itself notes that time will tell. Still, a loss is a poor setting in which to make a case for a player, and Skattebo made one anyway.
The bigger point is that New York's standing matters. The Giants are 3-5-1 or better in the division race only in the sense that they lead the NFC East pack by two games over Washington and one over Dallas, and Philadelphia has fallen to 2-7. The Giants are in position to win the division, and that makes a running back who can carry the offense more valuable than a deadline pickup who would have cost real draft capital.
My verdict is that the Giants should keep riding Skattebo and see whether Thursday was a turning point. If the rushing attack holds up over the next few weeks, the front office will have saved a second-round-level asset and found a answer in-house. If it does not, the team can still look at the market in the offseason. For now, the decision not to chase Taylor looks like the right one.